When “Natural” Isn’t Working: Hope For the Discouraged Crunchy Mother

When "Natural" Isn't Working: Hope for the Discouraged Crunchy Mama {KeeperoftheHome.org}

By Jessica Smartt, Contributing Writer

When my son was 18 months old, I put him down for his afternoon nap. Nothing unusual, except he had a bad cold, and was feeling yucky. Thirty minutes later, I heard him wake up, uncomfortable.

When I walked into the room, I was shocked at what I saw.

He was coughing – not just coughing – gasping through every breath. His ribs and neck muscles were retracting. He was trying to talk, but had to gasp before every couple of words.

I’m a compulsive worrier, but this time, I knew there was something wrong. I called my mom, buckled him with shaky hands, and rushed to the doctor.

A few long hours later, we took a memorable ambulance ride to the downtown children’s hospital, where we stayed for two days, until his oxygen levels rose back to normal.

When "Natural" Isn't Working: Hope for the Discouraged Crunchy Mama {KeeperoftheHome.org}

Here’s where I get to my confession part.

Since that (terrifying) day four years ago, my son has been off and on a slew of various asthma medications. Inhaled cortisteroids, albuterhol…

And it gets worse.

Once or twice a year, we have to give my son oral steroids. Prednisone. Even the word makes my stomach lurch. I know it’s bad because even the mainstream medical professionals – the “un-crunchy” crowd – hate using this stuff.

Please do not remind me how horrible this medicine is.

I know.

I know it every time we have to give it. I know it every time we totter near giving it, when my husband and I get on our knees (literally – how many times have we been on our knees for this child?), and we beg God to open his airways, to keep his lungs healthy, to let us not have to give us this awful medicine.

Sometimes it works: the prayers, the oils, the diet changes, the supplements – maybe all working together. Sometimes we’re spared, and his breathing returns to normal.

But others…

I cannot tell you how deeply I feel like a failure using these medicines. Nothing feels worse to a crunchy mom than her efforts not working. Of course, I have a long, long list of remedies and helps and aids that I have eagerly tried. They often help, but none for us has been a once-and-for-all cure. We deal with life-threatening food allergies, and trust me – that is crazy difficult.

When "Natural" Isn't Working: Hope for the Discouraged Crunchy Mama {KeeperoftheHome.org}

But this? This is the worst. When you try so desperately to fix something…and you can’t. Maybe you don’t have a child with asthma and bear the frustration of that awful disease.

Perhaps you can relate to my frustration?

A pesky sinus infection, a surgery you just can’t put off, resistant ear infections in a little one … or maybe something worse. Maybe you deal with a chronic ailment that may (or may not) respond to all your crunchy methodology.

If you’ve been there, I feel for you. Here are some things I’ve learned as a crunchy-mama-in-the-journey.

  • Just because you need some “conventional” medication, doesn’t mean your efforts are all in vain. Sometimes I will be so sure that my latest concoction will just cure my son’s asthma for good, and it doesn’t. I’ll whine to my husband, Why don’t we just give up, and put him on five different medicines, and let him eat whatever junk food he wants? None of it does any good anyway! And my sweet husband will remind me (as he often does in my embarrassing struggles): Sweetie. It is working. It is helping. Sometimes it’s just a big battle to fight. But you’re doing a great job.
  • Just because something “natural” isn’t working, doesn’t mean there isn’t a natural cure. Just because you haven’t found the answer, doesn’t mean there isn’t an answer. It is okay to be in process of discovering what can heal the body. Let me repeat that:

When "Natural" Isn't Working: Hope for the Discouraged Crunchy Mama {KeeperoftheHome.org}

It is okay to be in the process of natural living.

There may be people who have “reached” the destination. But for many like me, we are still learning what does and does not work, doing our best as we go along. And that is okay.

  • You have to remain upbeat, and open to trying new things. I bet after writing this, I’ll receive a host of asthma tricks and techniques that I’ve never even tried!  Instead of being defensive, or embarrassed, or afraid to try this or that, I’m learning to be grateful for yet another option to try!
  • Sometimes (and I’m wincing as I tell you this), you just take a deep breath, and do the horrible awful “conventional” thing, and thank the good Lord that you live in an age of modern medicine. Grace, mama. There is grace. I still believe that one day I’ll figure it out, and my son won’t need that steroid once a year. I truly do. But for now? When he needs it? When he’s struggling for breath, and coughs through every word? Friend, I will give this medicine, and I will thank God that I can.
  • And finally, I’ve been reminded that natural living is not my Savior. Jesus is. Because I’m a Christian, I take a weird sort of comfort in all my “failures.” Why? Because they remind me that this earth is not my home.  That one day – daily dose of cod liver oil or not – I will die. And that’s okay – because I will be with Jesus forever. The struggles we have on earth can serve as a reminder that there is a better life coming.

So, what about you? Have you, too, felt the disappointment of a failed remedy, or a natural journey in-the-process? What helps you when you feel like a discouraged crunchy mother?

About Jessica Smartt

Jessica Smartt is a former middle-school teacher who lives in beautiful North Carolina. You can find her at www.smarttereachday.com where she enjoys poking fun at the everyday challenges of motherhood, sharing delicious allergy-free recipes, and rejoicing that God still loves her no matter what phobia she has recently developed. She is blessed beyond belief with two Smartt little boys and a husband who can fix anything.

Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. Thank you so much for this post. I have been in process of learning to live naturally since my now 5 year old was born. Then a few months ago I found out that my (then 4 year old) son had a rare form of kidney cancer. The tumor had crawled out of his kidney, up his vena cava and to his heart. I simply did not feel I had time to research and implement the many natural cancer cures as this tumor was already invading the heart of my always before perfectly healthy child. And I understand there are many natural remedies because the crunchy world can sometimes be rather judgmental when you choose conventional medicine and I have been told of many “tried and true” natural cures for cancer that I should have tried before resorting to radiating my child and filling him full of toxic chemotherapy poison. But I chose conventional medicine and though we are still in treatment he is currently cancer free as far as we can tell. I know we will have to live with the side effects of these treatments for the rest of his life, but I am thankful to God for every day we get to worry about those side effects, because it means my baby is still here. I am still learning of natural ways to supplement his therapy, but Thank you for easing some of that lingering guilt that I have about choosing this course.

  2. Dr. Allie the Health Guru says:

    Wow, this is so beautifully written. Thank you for sharing your deepest and most sincere thoughts and feelings. God bless.

  3. THANK YOU for this! Just this week I have had to make the awful decision to give two of my daughters steroids for a severe reaction to poison ivy, and amixicillin to my little one miserable with a double ear infection.words cannot express how much this post means to me.if only I’d seen it sooner – it would have spared me some angst!!!

  4. I can relate to this so well. I’m a very “crunchy” lady, yet I take Zoloft for my OCD and anxiety issues. I tried all the “natural” remedies, but none of them quite did the trick. The GAPS diet is out of the question for me as I simply don’t have the resources to follow it. My OCD was so bad that I could literally think about nothing other than my obsession and compulsive behaviors, and I had regular panic attacks because the stress of it was so overwhelming. I had always told myself that pharmaceutical drugs would be my absolute last resort. And, well, I took the dreaded pharmaceuticals and don’t regret it for an instant. They’ve made a vast improvement in my mental health and life overall, and I’ve come to terms with the fact that I can allow myself this “cheat” in my crunchiness.

  5. Cynysha Thompson says:

    I don’t have children BUT ………. I completely understand this mother’s situation because it ALL applies to me PERSONALLY!! She has NO reason to feel like a failure! I was born with an impaired immune system and as a result I live an anything BUT ‘normal’ life. Even the clothes I wear MUST be made a certain way of certain materials and I cannot wear colors. I have been cleaning up my life now for over five years and if I hadn’t I WOULDN’T be alive. Living a natural or organic existence isn’t easy in a highly toxic environment and it is possible. I asked God to take control and lead me in ALL things and I have found that I am MORE healthy than many who have never even considered the drastic changes I’ve made.


  1. […] When “Natural” Isn’t Working: Hope For the Discouraged Crunchy Mother | Keeper of … […]

  2. […] way of living can be overwhelming.  But give yourself grace and take it one step at a time.  Encouragement for When Natural isn’t Working will help give you some peace for you Natural […]

  3. […] coincidental, yet so perfectly aligned, that I would feel led to write this post the same week that Jessica’s thoughtful post on such a similar topic went up. I think the message is coming through loud and clear… “grace, always […]

  4. […] month’s post at Keeper of the Home was very personal for me. It’s hard to admit on a huge “natural living” blog like […]