My Review of doTERRA Essential Oils (and how much of a difference does quality really make?)

UHomB 600x345

Are you looking for ways to improve your homemaking skills? How about some new recipes?

Or maybe you really need some inspiration for your faith, your mothering, your marriage

What if you could get all these things and more, in one HUGE awesome package of digital resources (plus $200 of bonus freebies) for less than $30?

The Ultimate Homemaking Bundle is 95% off of retail value and worth almost $900! Interested?

Read more here!

doterra review

Written by Stephanie Langford, Creator of Keeper of the Home

Although I am in love with using natural remedies, including herbs and essential oils, I have remained skeptical about just how much of a difference the particular brand of oils that you use really makes. Perhaps you, like me, have heard what you deem to be “hype” about this brand or that one, and wonder if it’s there’s really anything to it or if it makes no difference.

If I’m being honest, that’s how I felt every time someone  commented or emailed and told me about doTERRA oils and how amazing they were. I’d secretly roll my eyes and think “here we go again”.

I have to go eat a slice of pie now. Humble pie.

For the past two months or so, I have been testing out a number of doTERRA oils, both Singles and Blends, through Modern Wellness. Christy from Modern Wellness asked me back in October whether I would consider reviewing some oils, and I decided to give in and said yes. She asked me for some of the health concerns or needs for our family, and then sent a wonderful package full of oils in the mail.

At this point, I got a little bit excited. See, I’ve been falling in love with essential oils over the past two years, as much as a skeptic as I was that these particular ones were any different, I do enjoy experimenting with them and learning how we can better use them for our health and well being.

She also sent me an amazing essential oil reference book, Modern Essentials, which lists every single oil and every blend carried by doTERRA, with detailed instructions on how to use them, as well as a section in the back with all sorts of illnesses, ailments, mood and behavior struggles, etc. and then numerous ideas for various oils that could be used in each situation. This book was invaluable to me, both in delving into my review of these oils, and also in becoming more experienced in using essential oils in general.

a few doterra blends

Here’s what we thought of the oils we tried:

  • Deep Blue Rub- This is my favorite, hands down. It is similar to an icy blue rub, like what you might buy at the pharmacy, but a million times better. You can buy it either as an oil blend, or as a lotion that is already mixed with the oils (this is what we tried). It has a beautiful blue color to it, which actually comes from the oils. It smells divine. Every time I or my husband used it, we commented again on how incredible it smelled. Even better, it was such a soothing balm to my sore, tight muscles (courtesy of a car accident we were in earlier this summer). I used it on my worst nights/days and it definitely gave a good measure of relief. I really, really want to buy more of this stuff.
  • Serenity- This is another oil blend, with lavender, sweet marjoram, roman chamomile, ylang ylang, sandalwood and vanilla bean. I sometimes struggle with insomnia, and this is the oil that I would dab just lightly on my wrists and the pulse points on my neck before going to bed. I honestly found myself sniffing my wrists as I went to bed, because the scent relaxed me so much. I can definitely say that this blend helped me to sleep better on the nights that I needed it. I also tried it on my daughters on two different occasions, when they were upset about something and just couldn’t go to sleep, and this really helped to calm them down so that they could rest.
  • Lavender- I’ve been using lavender oil for a long time, but this is the purest, strongest, most beautiful smelling lavender I’ve ever used.
  • Balance- Can I just say that whoever works at doTERRA and puts together their blends is talented beyond belief? Every single blend that we tried smelled absolutely heavenly, this one being no exception. I used this one on days when I felt stressed and unbalanced. Sometimes I put it on my feet and pulse points on my neck, and other times I put it in my nebulizer (this distributes miniscule drops of the oils into the air in a very fine mist, so that you both smell and inhale them gradually). I could tell that it helped to keep my more calm and level-headed.
  • On Guard- This was a very close second to the Deep Blue Rub as my favorite scent. I used this one mostly in the nebulizer to help keep everyone healthy when colds/flus started going around where we live. As for how well it works, I’m not sure. I did use it on myself when I as really sick and I couldn’t particularly notice a difference.
  • Wild Orange and Peppermint (these were both Singles, not a combination)- Again, I was incredibly impressed with the purity of these oils, just like with the lavender. The orange was even orange-tinted and smelled so sweet. The peppermint was strong and I hardly had to use any of it for a good effect. Christy had said to try these two together, and so that’s what I did in my nebulizer and the scent was beautiful and very energizing. It’s my new happy smell (well, that and Balance). I also used the orange (diluted with the fractionated coconut oil) on my baby when he experienced some constipation. The book said to rub it on his feet and tummy, and when I did so a couple times, it seemed to stimulate his system and help clear up the problem. It was around the time when I was sick, so it may have had to do with being slightly dehydrated since I was struggling with my milk supply a little, but nonetheless, the orange oil did the trick until he was back to normal.
  • Past Tense- She sent me this one because I had been experiencing headaches, but wouldn’t you know it, I haven’t had too many since having this oil blend around. I did try it a few times and I found that if I had a headache that was still mild or just beginning, it worked really well to counteract it. If I waited too long and it turned into a migraine (which I’ve had occasionally since the car accident) then it helped a little but it seemed like it was a bit too late to make a difference at that point.
  • In Tune- I wanted something to help my 5 year old focus a bit more during homeschool, because he’s very easily distracted (I know, all 5 year olds are, but he can be particularly so). I didn’t always remember to use it, but when I did, I would rub it on the bottoms of his feet (which made him giggle, but he enjoyed it and liked the scent). The difference wasn’t dramatic, but it was noticeable. I also took to using it on myself a few times when I felt really scatterbrained and though that it focused me a little better, but again.
orange color of oil doterra

This is the orange oil, a few drops poured onto an off-white baby cloth. You can clearly see the orange color of the oil.

My overall thoughts of the doTERRA oils

  1. They seem to be very pure and strong. I already have lavender, peppermint and orange, so I compared each of them with the ones from doTERRA and definitely noticed a difference. The doTERRA oils seemed stronger, sweeter, and had a more true scent, and even retained just a slight bit of color. I also felt that maybe I could use less than I normally would, because of the strength. I made a glass with a couple drops of peppermint oil, as I sometimes do for an upset tummy, and the oil was way too strong. I had to pour half of it out and just fill it up with water. One drop would have been enough.
  2. The blends are incredible. I wish that I could make my own blends, but even though I have a wide array of different oils (probably 12+ different ones) that really isn’t enough to make well-balanced blends. Beyond that, it just takes a lot of knowledge and skill to put together blends that are both effective and pleasing to smell. My husband even specifically asked me if I was going to buy any of the blends, especially the Deep Blue Rub.
  3. They’re expensive. I would like to be able to buy these oils, particularly some of the blends that we loved, but I do find the cost a bit prohibitive. I’m used to paying more like $5-$25 per bottle (depending on which oil it is, prices vary), but these oils are more like $13-$50+. To make them affordable, you can join as a Wholesale Member, for $35 start up and $25 yearly fees. You can then purchase oils at significantly lower prices (at least 25% lower), as well as earn points and rewards for what you do buy. I calculated it a bit and I think that if you used essential oils frequently, this would probably work out to make them reasonably affordable. Note that this is an MLM (multi-level marketing) company, but that’s too big a ball of yarn to tackle in this post, so I’ll suffice it to say MLMs can have both good and bad points. :)

Common questions about essential oils

This is where we get to the frustrating area of hot debate, unknown answers, differing points of view, hype, and all that fun stuff.

First of all, I’ll state that this is a sponsored review, by Christy of Modern Wellness, who is a doTERRA rep. The primary focus of this post is to review the products that she sent me. I also want to say that as far as reps go, she is the first one that I chose to work with, because I really liked how she approached me, her completely non-pushy attitude, how much she wanted to share good information to help people, and she’s just been a pleasure to work with overall (thanks, Christy!). If you’re going to buy doTERRA, I highly recommend doing it through Christy.

I do know that because I have readers that like to analyze and dig into the details as much as I do, I can’t just let it go without addressing some of these questions as well as best as I can.

I am nowhere near an essential oil expert, but just a wife and mom that seeks out alternative natural remedies for my family. I do the best research I can with the limited time that I have. Some of you will disagree with me on some of these points, and some of you will wish I had provided more detailed/scientific answers, and I’ll apologize in advance for that, but this is my basic understanding of the issue as a non-expert, so just take it all with a grain of salt.

1. What is a “pure” essential oil?

From my limited reading, I understand that for an essential oil to be pure, it should:

  • Be extracted using a low-temperature and low-pressure system. Steam distillation is the preferred process, and ideally the oils should be from the first distillation.
  • Not contain any other ingredients whatsoever. It should be 100% pure oil. However, we should take a clue from the food industry and realize that “pure” doesn’t necessarily mean pure when used on a package. There are companies selling cheap oils that have other oils or fillers added, to boost their profit margins. As Adrienne wisely stated, if the price seems to good to be true, it likely is. Genuine essential oils are not cheap to produce.
  • Ideally, the oils should be from a first distillation. That said, I have been reading that sometimes you get different qualities from the second or third distillation, and some companies do blend the oils from multiple distillations to come up with their final product (yes, doTERRA being one of them for a handful of their oils). Not being an expert in this area, I don’t want to just say “first distillation only” because I don’t honestly know if it’s any better or worse either way.
  • From one of two sources, either a) wildcrafted from where they naturally grow (this in an instance in which we don’t want locally grown- we want herbs and botanicals taken from where they originally come from, as this is where they will grow best and provide the most medicinal qualities, or so I’m told), or 2) from organic sources, to avoid any chemical contamination.

For a bit more reading on essential oil purity, Adrienne of Whole New Mom has been exploring the whole issue and this post (and the whole essential oil series) takes a closer look at the processes and the darker side of the industry.

It’s important to note that as with many natural health alternatives, there is no one governing standard or certification process for essential oils. doTERRA says it themselves on their website. There is AFNOR in France, which sets standards and regulations, but it is NOT a regulatory body.

Which means, everyone creates their own standards, tries to show how their processes are better than everyone else’s, and in the end, it’s difficult to know exactly what’s what. Honestly, in many regards, I’m as confused as the rest of you. Do the best research you can into the process, try the oils for yourself, and go with your gut on the ones that seem pure and effective for you.

2. Are essential oils safe to ingest? Any of them or only some brands?

Again, this is up for debate. If you’re using 100% pure oils, not cheap ones that may have chemical residues or unwanted filler ingredients, then my feeling is that it is probably fine. doTERRA specifically states that theirs are safe to ingest because of the purity, and I would personally apply that safety to any brand that is actually a pure oil as well.

That said, I personally think that we’re a bit too quick to take things internally, especially essential oils. I do use them in a few things, like my toothpaste recipe (which we spit out), and very occasionally a drop or two that we drink in water, and sometimes Oil of Oregano under the tongue. Other than that, I don’t like taking something so strong internally. You can get excellent results using them topically, or sometimes in the air (through something like a nebulizer- I love mine!).

two roll on doterra

These are two of their blends that come in roll-on bottles, for easy topical application.

3. How much does quality matter? Will they still work if I buy a cheaper brand?

Again, I don’t know for sure. I’ve used some cheaper brands over the years with limited success, but I mostly bought them for the scents or for cleaning purposes. As I’ve begun to use them more medicinally, I’ve preferred to find ones that are higher quality. Sometimes it requires trial and error.

I think it’s possible that some cheaper brands could still offer medicinal qualities and good results, but I do know for sure that I’ve seen real results from the higher quality oils I’ve tried. I was particularly happy with some of the results that I had with doTERRA oils, and it would be interesting to try to mimic those results using something else.

4. Do they honestly even work in the first place? There seems to be so much hype about essential oils.

I love essential oils and I do believe that they work. I’ve used them so many times over the past few years and have been very impressed with some of the results. For muscle pain and soreness, for headaches, for tummy troubles and constipation, for nerves and balancing moods and relaxation, for healing infections. I can say that from my experience, essential oils are a valuable part of my natural medicine cabinet.

5. If I can’t afford something like doTERRA, what else would you recommend?

I personally really like Mountain Rose Herbs oils, which I have just begun buying. I also like Saje oils (these might only be available in Canada), but they’re also pricey. Aromaforce sources their oils from native plants and is pure (again, Canadian company, but possibly available elsewhere). I’ve also heard many good things about Aura Cacia and Heritage.

I do think it’s worth it to check into the doTERRA Wholesale Membership option through Modern Wellness. You could contact Christy through her website or Facebook page to get a better idea of how the benefits work and what the discounts would be like.

Bottom line on doTERRA oils?

I didn’t know if I would notice a difference with doTERRA and I went into this skeptical, but I honestly was impressed by them. I really, genuinely liked them and found them to be effective. In my books, that’s enough for me to warrant a bit of extra research and to consider some higher costs, since I regularly use essential oils for our family’s health needs.

I also wanted to mention that when you buy oils through a rep, you’re more likely to get a high level of support. That’s worth something, because most of you aren’t essential oil experts (just as I’m not). Oh sure, we can google it and research it on our own, but we all know that there is a ton of unreliable information out there, mixed in with the trustworthy sources.

I appreciate how Christy shares helpful information on the Modern Wellness blog, website and Facebook page, and how she offers free webinars to further teach about the uses of essential oils. You aren’t likely to get that kind of help and information from most oil sources, and so that’s something to consider.

Do you use essential oils? What are some of the ways that you have found them to be helpful and effective for your family?

Also, I know that many of you are chomping at the bit to turn this into an EO brand debate. I’m all right with a few carefully worded comments sharing your opinions, but please, let’s keep it civil. I’ve seen such awful, nasty comments on this topic (it’s shocking, really!), and I just don’t care for that at all. We’re all adults, so let’s have a conversation like adults.

Disclosure: I received product from Modern Wellness for the purpose of review. This post has been generously sponsored by Modern Wellness, but the product reviews and all opinions on essential oils are my own.

About Stephanie Langford

Stephanie Langford has a passion for sharing ideas and information for homemakers who want to make healthy changes in their homes, and carefully steward all that they've been given. She has written three books geared to helping families live more naturally and eat real, whole foods, without being overwhelmed, without going broke and with simple meal planning. She is the creator of Keeper of the Home.

Read Newer Post
Read Older Post

Comments

  1. Do you know any different in quality between doTerra and young living essential oils? I’m very new with aromatherapy but I’m very interested.
    Thanks

  2. I have just attended an information evening learning about doTerra. Sounds like a wonderful product.
    One question I have that I am not seeing/hearing any comments on is – how often does a person use these oils, for example Deep Blue for arthritis – apply several or many times a day?

  3. I’m a newbie to essential oils, I spoke with a doterra rep and i bought the intro kit. I would like to buy more but they are so expensive. Has anyone tried Plant Therapy essential oils?

  4. My son was muscle tested to young living frankincense and do terra frankincense he did not test well to young living but tested very well to do terra so that clearly tells me which is more pure. Thanks for your review.

  5. Before you use any more doTerra, you may want to learn how they have been recently independently lab tested and found to have the toxic synthetic vanillin in their peppermint oil… that is why it smells like candy cane!
    I use to be with DoTerra myself…… This is truth, google… “certified synthetic” and you will find it.. here is some info on vanillin. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/jps.3030291001/abstract I then discovered more unethical information about DoTerra and my heart sunk completely as I had invested about $1500 or more in their product…. They do not own their own farms, you cannot go and see any farms, plant on farms, see their distillation plants, they still buy from brokers and when other companies have turned down another essential oil as (because each batch should be tested prior to bottling to ensure the highest of quality and that the chemical compounds from the plant to oil are the exact same…) DoTerra was found to still have purchased it…. This was a shock and disappointing as I had trusted my emotions, my mind and my dollars into this product. And as someone above mentioned… DoTerra just trademarked the name certified therapeutic…. it doesn’t mean it is…. They were too money hungry for me… Now that I know the truth I threw out most of their oils except to use as comparisons… Yvonne

    • Yvonne…It seems you have been misinformed by a company from whom these claims of “certified synthetic” have been made. In case you are unaware, and to set the record straight for anyone else who reads your post, a lawsuit has been made in response to the false claims and mudslinging which has been made to defame doTERRA and the quality of their oils. You can see the facts and complete details of what has transpired and filed with the United States District Court here:
      http://www.doterra.com/tools/documents/DN_2_Complaint_United_States__Australia_New_Zealand__Europe__Canada_3821.pdf
      The evidence actually points to the unethical nature of the leadership in Young Living and perpetuating lies that were deliberate in falsifying information. Fortunately everything is coming to light now, with the exception it seems of those in YL who are being kept from the truth. And the truth is that doTERRA’s standard has remained of highest quality. In fact, from now through September 15th, they have issued a “Peppermint Challenge” ….for any person who wants to experience the doTERRA difference they can send a bottle of any high quality peppermint oil of any brand to doTERRA and they will in return send a free bottle of Peppermint with a certificate of analysis of the oils sent from an independent laboratory for free.
      You’re right, Yvonne, in that doTERRA doesn’t own their own farms, which reaffirms their therapeutic quality. They in fact source their oils from around the world where they are indigenous to their environment, unlike some companies who farm them. doTERRA works with individual growers all over the world to ensure the integrity of the oils is not compromised, and nothing is added to or taken away from. And, they are certified pure by third party labs, and even validated by Dr. Robert Pappas who is independent and probably the worlds foremost expert in essential oil research.
      In the end, Certified Pure Therapeutic Grade does matter, and is what has made the difference in my life. I’ve used all the major oil brands out there, but thankfully I’ve found my home here with doTERRA.

  6. Nice post. I am a doTERRA rep (albeit a ‘small time’ one) and the wholesale option you mentioned is great for making the oils affordable…I’m able to get a good supply of oils every month for either free or maybe $20 out of pocket b/c of commissions I receive…so it’s totally doable for anyone who’s interested : )

  7. Jan Schmidt says:

    I’ve been using Young Living essential oils for 7 years now & wouldn’t change/give them up for anything! They are the leaders in the industry, they laboratory test all their oils and they grow a lot of their own plants on several company-owned farms. When you compare their oils side-by-side to others you can smell/feel/taste the difference. Others in this blog have warned not to ingest essential oils – that is true if they are adulterated like most on the market, but not true of YL oils. I have been ingesting them for 7 years with amazing results. When you put something on your skin it goes right into your blood stream anyway – so what’s the difference? I am off all my allergy prescriptions, never need an antibiotic (I’ve used the oils to kill strep & shingles for example), and have nothing but YL oils in my medicine cabinet :)

  8. Hi Stephanie,
    Another blog I read also reviewed some of the major EO players, and mentioned Mountain Rose as well. Do you know if Mountain Rose has an “intune” type blend also? I’d love to help my son with his focus also! :)

  9. JASMINE says:

    Just because an essential oil has supplement information does not make it safe for daily ingestion undiluted in the proper way. There is too much miseducation and mis understanding. Spreading the use of essential oils this way is unethical and unsafe. I am a CCAP trained in the clinical use of essential oils

  10. Hi Christi…I really enjoyed your article. I have a dear friend who is really excited about these oils not only for the health benefits but also as a business. Your info was concise and interesting. I am considering giving them a try as well. I am really into homeopathic medicine and try to go the natural route whenever possible. L

  11. Michelle Patterson says:

    I love my essential oils…can’t live without them! Thanks for sharing!
    #oils4everyone

  12. Hi Stephanie. I enjoyed this wonderful, nuanced post. I too have the same reaction when I hear people push one brand or another. I am new to Aromatherapy, so I have been buying what is easiest for me to access, Aura Cacia, and am having wonderful therapeutic results. Being new and still exploring I don’t want to buy the expensive brands because already I’ve made a few mistakes in choosing things that are far too stimulating for us for every day use. Once I know my core oils I will explore other brands, like DoTerra and YLO. My Autistic son is having AMAZING results with Vertiver and it is having a positive effect on me, too. As for taking essential oils internally, I never do it. They will kill the beneficial probiotics in the gut just like an antibiotic will. Some of the multi-level marketing advocates criticize Aura Cacia for putting don’t take internally on the label, but the fact that they put that on there doesn’t bother me. In order to be allowed to be labeled food grade essential oils have to be slightly altered per Codex and A.C. doesn’t alter. Since they are sold in grocery stores people often confuse their oils for food additives, so it is helpful to put it on the bottle. So that is the other side of the story, from what I’ve learned in my investigations. Food grade oils like DoTerra are still clearly therapeutic, so whatever the alteration is doesn’t seem to be a problem. I want to try Rose Mountain’s oils because I am very, very impressed with that company’s sustainability commitments and Fair Trade practices.

  13. Michelle Patterson says:

    Great info, thanks for sharing!
    #oils4everyone

  14. As an Aromatherapist of 24 years, there are quite a few comments on this thread that cause me serious alarm. “All pure oils are safe to ingest” there is no regulatory body in the world that recognises ingestion of essential oils as safe practice. A distributor that suggests this to a customer who suffers from high blood pressure, heart condition, diabetes, epilepsy is asking for a law suit against them. Unbelievable!
    Also the term “Therapeutic Grade Essential Oil” is a marketing tool. It is a trademark term. There is no standard used for essential oil using the words ‘Therapeutic Grade’. The quality of your Essential Oils are determined by your supplier being able to tell you, Country of Origin, Botanical name, date of crop harvested and extracted, type of extraction used, guarantee of one particular harvest per volume, shelf life, material safety data analysis reports..by this I don’t mean reports from an MLM company, but from government regulated scientific sources. Please do your own research. I don’t think I like the ethical practice of Aromatherapy being infiltrated by MLM companies..cheers

    • thats very intresting what u said about ingesting essential oil, i recently come across boswellia sacra oil and i been drinking it in tea and found it amazing it really relaxes me, how do i know if its safe to consume ? please advise me, thanks

      • Hi Helen
        I do not advocate the ingestion of any essential oils. As I mentioned previously there is no regulatory body in the world that recommends ingestion of essential oils as safe practice. There are many other safe herbal teas that you could drink instead of boswellia sacra oil (frankincense) for relaxation. MLM companies that sell essential oils are not regulatory bodies. You will have to look up the appropriate organisations in your own country and do your own research. Cheers

    • So, Linda….then what is it that YOU use and that YOU recommend?

  15. I clean with water, vinegar, lemon, peppermint, and tea tree. Lemon helps get rid of the nasty dirt, peppermint kills bacteria and smells fresh, and tea tree kills mold. I also sometimes add cinnamon to help kill some types of viruses.

  16. This is a great blog, I have referred to it several times to give to my clients interested in purchasing doTERRA Products from me.

    Thank you for your honest assessment of the oils!

  17. Hi,
    I have been learning about the additional healing capabilities of using essential oils and I just want to clarify that the only ones that should or could be used for internal healing are the ones that clearly have the supplement title stated on their label. I have only seen this distinction on doTERRA’s oils thus far.
    Joan Zietlow BSN, RN, CHHC
    Health and Wellness Expert

Trackbacks

  1. [...] about essential oils in another KIOS post and in this post (which has a review of doTerra oils at the beginning and some good basic info about essential oils [...]

  2. [...] I trusted for this sort of information.  I came upon a review of doTERRA oils by Stephanie over at Keeper of the Home.  Her review was honest and compelling, and it was through this review that I found my [...]

  3. [...] we're talking about an essential oil that you've probably heard of before or have even seen in recipes for homemade cleaners here at [...]

  4. [...] just for you! You’ve probably seen Stephanie announce our webinars and she recently did a review of doTERRA’s essential oils. We wanted to give one lucky winner the opportunity to win [...]